The doggie poop bag dispenser is pretty durable. The clip/clasp part hasn’t broken off yet. And we’ve had it for over a year. Most break off easily so I like that it also screws on the opening to prevent it from falling off.The flashlight however, is a bit defective. There will be times we’re walking of dog and the flashlight would just turn on automatically. Probably from the swaying of the leash? Other than that it’s not a terrible product. It doesn’t bother me much (not that hard to push the button to turn it off)I was super happy with these for the first 6-8 months. One flashlight got corroded in the battery area and stopped working, the other quit for no reason a month later. They hold poop bags well & I love that they sent extra batteries, but new batteries don’t help when the light is broken.Not even sure where to start, the fact that there is a light on a poo bag dispenser is so convenient b/c most of the time you walk out the house to only walk the dog so no phone etc. The surprises kept coming they send spare batteries and one is already in place, their are 3 lanyard like attachments to affix the poo bags or to the leash. The next good thing is the bags are scented and sturdyOne day after 1 month return window it has a short in it & is non returnable! Bigger problem is that the most I used the light was 10 short times!!! It should have lasted way longer than 1 month. I did really like it until today.In general, the item is cool. but I dont receive the metal clip.I love it at night when walking my pet and I can see where he poops. Light just keeps going in and out even with new batteries.These are great we use one on each of our girls leashes. The bags we use fit perfect and the light is great at night to pick up after them!I love everything about these! The flashlight is fantastic and it comes with extra batteries and it already has bags inside. What more could you ask for?!